Tax Alerts

FL – Taxpayer properly applied cost-of-performance rule to its income producing activities

An out of state subsidiary (taxpayer) of a nationwide online and brick-and-mortar retailer (retailer) properly sourced its service revenue under the state’s cost-of-performance (COP) rule, for Florida corporate income tax purposes.

In this matter, the retailer and its subsidiary (taxpayer) entered into a Retail Operating Services Agreement (ROSA). Under ROSA, the taxpayer provided merchandising, marketing, and strategy and management consulting services to the retailer. The subsidiary owned no real or tangible personal property in Florida during the tax years at issue. However, it had a small amount of payroll attributed to Florida.

The Florida Department of Revenue (department) conducted an audit to determine the taxpayer’s compliance with the state income tax laws. Subsequently, the department proposed adjustments to the taxpayer’s corporate income tax liability contending that the taxpayer was required to attribute its service receipts to Florida based on a fraction the numerator of which was the retail square footage of the retailer’s stores across the country.

The taxpayer countered the adjustment and stated that the department’s rule required that its sales receipts must be attributed to Florida based on the location of the income producing activity directly engaged in by the taxpayer, which is determined based on the location of the costs to perform those services. Since the location of the costs to perform services under the ROSA were those of the taxpayer’s employees residing outside Florida, the taxpayer argued that the department’s administrative rule attributed none of the taxpayer’s sales receipts to Florida.

Generally, under the COP rule, service revenue is attributable to Florida if the “income producing activity” responsible for generating the sales revenue is performed by the taxpayer in Florida. If the “income producing activity” is not conducted solely in Florida, the COP rule states that the sales revenue is attributable to Florida if the “greater proportion of the income producing activity is performed in Florida, based on costs of performance.”

The department argued that the taxpayer failed to provide sufficient documentation to support the use of the COP apportionment method. However, the taxpayer asserted that it provided state-by-state payroll, property and sales apportionment work-papers, and working trail balance information to the auditors. Moreover, in response to the department’s request, the taxpayer provided its payroll apportionment worksheet and related supporting document to substantiate its use of the COP apportionment method.

Upon review, the circuit court noted that the taxpayer provided sufficient documentation to the department. The court also noted that the COP rule operates in two steps:

(1)
determining the taxpayer’s income producing activity; and

(2)
balancing of the costs incurred to perform that activity.

If the greater proportion of the costs to perform the activity are incurred outside Florida, as the court noted, none of the receipts are apportioned to Florida. In this matter, the taxpayer’s income producing activities were performing services under the ROSA and the greater proportion of the costs to perform the taxpayer’s services were incurred outside Florida.

Accordingly, the taxpayer properly apportioned its income under COP rules and therefore the taxpayer’s protest was sustained. Target Enterprise, Inc. v. Florida Department of Revenue, Circuit Court, 2nd Judicial Circuit (Florida), No. 2021-CA-002158, November 28, 2022

Energy Credit Online Tool Now Available to Sellers, IR-2023-202

The IRS has announced that enrollment to the IRS Energy Credit Online tool is now open to the sellers of clean vehicles. The Energy Credits tool is available free of cost and will […]

Read More
Energy Credit Online Tool Now Available to Sellers, IR-2023-202

IRS Offers Cybersecurity Tips, IR-2023-200

The IRS and Security Summit partners reminded taxpayers to remain vigilant against potential cybersecurity threats. As the National Cybersecurity Awareness Month is […]

Read More
IRS Offers Cybersecurity Tips, IR-2023-200

IRS Cautions Against Charity Scams Amid Global Crisis, IR-2023-196

The IRS has issued a warning to taxpayers, advising them to be cautious of fraudulent solicitors who pretend to represent genuine charities. These […]

Read More
IRS Cautions Against Charity Scams Amid Global Crisis, IR-2023-196

Low and Moderate Income Taxpayers Can Save More through Saver’s Credit in 2024, IR-2023-222

The IRS has reminded low and moderate income taxpayers that they can save more for their retirement now through Saver’s Credit. This credit is available to taxpayers who are 18 years […]

Read More
Low and Moderate Income Taxpayers Can Save More through Saver’s Credit in 2024, IR-2023-222

IRS Reminds IRA Owners of Tax-Free Charitable Transfer Option, IR-2023-215

The IRS has reminded individual retirement arrangement (IRA) owners, aged 70½ or older, of tax-free charitable transfers permitting senior citizens to contribute up to $100,000 annually to eligible charities […]

Read More
IRS Reminds IRA Owners of Tax-Free Charitable Transfer Option, IR-2023-215

IRS Urges Taxpayers to Review Withholding, IR-2023-205

The IRS has urged taxpayers to promptly review their tax withholding to avoid surprises, whether in the form of significant refunds or balances due when filing taxes next […]

Read More
IRS Urges Taxpayers to Review Withholding, IR-2023-205

FL - Change in Collier County local communications services tax rates announced

Effective January 1, 2024, the Florida local communications services tax (CST) rates in Collier County are as follows: 2.1% in […]

Read More
FL - Change in Collier County local communications services tax rates announced

FL - Guidance on credit for human milk fortifier manufacturing equipment issued

Florida issued guidance regarding a corporate income tax credit for manufacturing equipment purchased for the production of human breast milk […]

Read More
FL - Guidance on credit for human milk fortifier manufacturing equipment issued

FL - Guidance on internship tax credit program issued

Florida issued guidance regarding the student internship credit program for corporate income taxpayers. The program has been renamed as the […]

Read More
FL - Guidance on internship tax credit program issued

IRS Introduces Expanded Chatbot Technology to Assist Taxpayers with Underreporting Notices, IR-2023-78

The Service has introduced an expanded chatbot to promptly address inquiries of taxpayers receiving notices about possible underreporting of taxes. The new chatbot feature will assist taxpayers receiving CP2000 , CP2501 and CP3219A notices. This tech […]

Read More
IRS Introduces Expanded Chatbot Technology to Assist Taxpayers with Underreporting Notices, IR-2023-78